“Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don’t matter, and those who matter don’t mind” -Dr. Seuss
There’s a quiet weight a lot of teenagers carry that we don’t talk about enough.
It’s not GPA stress. It’s not roster cuts or social media pressure.
It’s this:
They’re scared to be fully themselves.
And I get it.
Being a teenager is brutal. You’re expected to act like an adult in situations where adults still get nervous. You’re discovering your voice, figuring out your values, and trying to fit in… while somehow also standing out enough to be noticed, liked, and maybe even recruited.
And in that emotional tug-of-war, a lot of kids stop short of ever showing the world who they really are. I was that kid.
Why aren’t they trying harder?
I see it all the time in recruiting. A kid with a massive serve or elite quickness holds back. Not because they aren’t capable. But because they’re constantly calculating:
“If I go all in, will I look like I’m trying too hard?”
“If I speak up, will people think I’m full of myself?”
“If I stand out, what happens when I mess up?”
These aren’t lazy athletes. These are hesitant athletes. And hesitation is rooted in insecurity.
They’re not wondering if they can perform at a high level.
They’re wondering if people will still accept them if they do.
And that fear of rejection? That’ll hold even the most talented kid back more than any missed rep or coaching cue.
The Quiet Risk of Conformity
So many young people would rather blend in than bet on who they truly are.
Why? Because when you blend in, you stay safe.
Safe from judgment. Safe from being the butt of the group chat. Safe from being misunderstood.
But you also stay small.
And greatness doesn’t grow where fear is fertilized.
The biggest hurdle for many teenagers today isn’t their work ethic, or their coach, or their talent.
It’s their inner voice that whispers:
“Tone it down. Fit in. Don’t risk it.”
The World Needs You to Fly Your Full Flag
In the play Hamlet, Polonius’ advice to his son Laertes hits different these days:
“To thine own self be true.”
Not partially true.
Not true only when it’s cool or convenient.
But fully, unapologetically, courageously YOU.
That kind of authenticity is rare—and rare is valuable. Especially in a world full of filters and followers.
It’s not easy. You’ll second-guess yourself. People might not get it at first.
But the irony is: the more you show your real self, the more respect you earn from the right people.
Teammates trust it. Coaches love it. Real friends are drawn to it.
And you start living and playing from a place of freedom instead of fear.
To the Teen Trying to Be the “Real” You…
Here’s what I want you to know:
You don’t need to shrink your voice or dim your effort to fit someone else’s comfort zone.
You were wired to stand out—not by being loud or flashy, but by being honest, hardworking, and real.
If you love something—pursue it with passion.
If you value something—speak on it with conviction.
If you believe something—live it boldly.
Some people won’t understand, and that’s okay. They weren’t meant to fly your flag anyway.
But when you do this right, you’ll stop living in fear of “what if they don’t accept me,”
and start living in pursuit of “what happens if I fully show up?”
Because that’s where the magic is.
That’s where peace is.
That’s where impact is.
Let’s Raise Kids Who Know This
Parents, coaches, teachers—we’ve got work to do too.
Let’s stop unintentionally rewarding conformity and start encouraging identity.
Ask kids who they are, not just what they want to do.
Celebrate their effort when they go all in, even if it’s a little messy.
And let’s be the kind of adults who don’t just say be yourself—but model it.
Because the world doesn’t need more polished, anxious performers.
It needs more bold, brave originals.
Let’s help our kids fly their flags—fully, freely, and without fear.
—
Want help guiding your teen athlete through this process?
That’s what Significant Recruiting is all about. Visit coachmattrogers.com to grab your copy of the book, check out the blog, or schedule a recruiting strategy session for your family.
